I want to talk a little about the poem, “The Day Lady Died,” by Frank O’Hara. I just think this poem is so magnificent in its ability to bring us into an ordinary, seemingly unimportant and busy day in New York City, and then into a profound memory of the narrator’s mind.
/
O’Hara was part of the New York School poetry movement, which was one of the last great Avant-garde movements in American poetry. And as I read this piece for the first time in Postmodern American Poetry, a Norton Anthology (which has an awesome cover by the way!) I was struck by how insignificant I felt the first four stanzas were (Initially of course). It’s not that I felt the tone seemed arrogant necessarily, but I just couldn’t relate to all of the names, and titles of plays and magazines. It seemed to represent an intellectual lifestyle, but in no way represented me as an average American reader. I couldn’t make an emotional connection.
Until we get to the last stanza of course, this wonderful and profound set of four lines,
The narrator walks past a magazine stand and sees Billie Holiday’s face- Lady Day has died.
/
We are taken to this other time, a seemingly simple time, but juxtaposed with that raw emotional realization of death. I can see O’Hara there in a New York Jazz club, leaning against the bathroom- I feel the warmth of the scene, and of the drinks and of the people. But most importantly, Billie Holiday is there, alive, in this memory “while she whispered a song along the keyboard.”
“Everyone and I stopped breathing.”
That breathlessness; now who can’t relate, in some way, to the beauty and the warmth of this scene. It makes what occurred in the beginning four stanzas seem so unimportant (which also makes them perfectly written) because of this news- this news that makes the narrator remember-
a moment that is truly important.
I just think this poem is awesome, and I love Billie Holiday too!
(Sorry I had to add the “/” between stanzas, I couldn’t figure out how to get the spacing right.